Complaints and Appeals
The Hed‑Core Academic Commons Journal is committed to handling complaints, appeals, and concerns fairly, confidentially, and promptly.
Scope
This procedure applies to complaints and appeals relating to:
-
Editorial decisions.
-
Peer-review conduct.
-
Editorial conduct.
-
Reviewer conduct.
-
Author conduct.
-
Published articles.
-
Publication ethics.
-
Research integrity.
-
Privacy, confidentiality, or data protection.
-
The Journal’s staff, editorial board, or publisher.
How to make a Complaint or Appeal
Concerns should be sent to the editorial office.
Email: editorial@hedcore.academiccommons.org
Complaints and appeals should include:
-
The manuscript or article title.
-
The manuscript ID, DOI, or URL, where applicable.
-
A clear explanation of the concern.
-
The date and nature of the event or decision, where relevant.
-
Any relevant supporting evidence.
-
The outcome or remedy sought.
Acknowledgement and Response
The Journal aims to acknowledge complaints and appeals within five working days.
The Journal will assess the matter fairly, confidentially, and promptly. Where appropriate, the Journal may seek further information, consult relevant individuals or institutions, obtain independent advice, or take interim measures while a concern is being considered.
Conflicts of Interest
Where a complaint or appeal concerns an editor or other individual involved in the handling of a submission, that individual will be recused from the assessment of the complaint or appeal where appropriate.
Appeals against Editorial Decisions
Authors may appeal an editorial decision where they believe that:
-
The decision was based on a factual error.
-
The decision did not adequately consider important information.
-
The peer-review process contained a material procedural concern.
-
New evidence or clarification materially affects the assessment.
Appeals should explain why the author believes the decision should be reconsidered. An appeal is not a guarantee that the original decision will be changed.
Complaints about Reviewers or Editors
Concerns about the conduct of a reviewer, editor, or other member of the editorial team should be reported to the editorial office.
The Journal will assess the concern fairly and may take appropriate action, including recusal, reconsideration, investigation, or referral to the publisher or governing body where necessary.
Confidentiality
Complaints and appeals will be handled confidentially. Information will be shared only with individuals who need to know in order to assess and resolve the matter.
Outcome
The Journal will communicate the outcome of a complaint or appeal to the person who raised it, subject to confidentiality obligations and applicable legal or institutional constraints.
Possible outcomes include:
-
No further action.
-
Clarification of the decision or process.
-
Reconsideration of an editorial decision.
-
Correction or amendment of a published record.
-
Expression of concern.
-
Retraction.
-
Referral to an institution, funder, publisher, or other appropriate body.
Escalation
Where a concern cannot be resolved through the Journal’s editorial office, it may be escalated to the Hed‑Core Academic Commons.
Artificial Intelligence Policy
Related pages:
Publication Ethics: /publication-ethics
Research Integrity: /research-integrity
Peer Review Policy: /peer-review-policy
Privacy and Data Protection: /privacy-and-data-protection
Contact: /contact