For Authors

Thank you for considering the Hed‑Core Academic Commons Journal as a venue for your work. These guidelines set out the Journal’s editorial expectations, manuscript-preparation requirements, ethical obligations, and submission procedures.

Authors are asked to read these guidelines carefully before submission. Manuscripts that do not meet the requirements set out below may be returned to authors before editorial assessment or peer review.

Editorial Scope and Aims

The Journal publishes scholarship that advances understanding, informs practice, supports evidence-informed decision-making, and contributes to responsible public engagement with knowledge.

The Journal welcomes submissions from a wide range of disciplinary, interdisciplinary, professional, and community-based perspectives. Work may be empirical, theoretical, conceptual, methodological, evaluative, practice-based, or synthesizing in nature.

Submissions should demonstrate:

  • A clearly articulated research question, aim, argument, or purpose.

  • Appropriate engagement with relevant scholarship, evidence, methods, or practice contexts.

  • Transparency in the presentation of data, sources, methods, analysis, and interpretation.

  • Careful consideration of limitations, uncertainty, and potential implications.

  • Ethical conduct and respect for the rights, dignity, privacy, and safety of individuals and communities.

  • Clear, accessible, and precise academic writing.

Article Types

Research Articles

Research Articles present original empirical, theoretical, conceptual, methodological, or interdisciplinary research. They should make a substantive contribution to knowledge and should situate their argument within relevant scholarship.

A Research Article should normally include:

  • Title

  • Abstract

  • Keywords

  • Introduction

  • Background or literature review

  • Research questions, aims, or hypotheses

  • Methods or approach

  • Results, findings, or analysis

  • Discussion

  • Limitations

  • Conclusion

  • References

  • Acknowledgements, funding, and conflict-of-interest statements

  • Appendices or supplementary materials, where applicable

Reviews and Evidence Syntheses

Reviews and Evidence Syntheses critically appraise, synthesize, or integrate existing evidence. Submissions may include systematic reviews, scoping reviews, rapid reviews, narrative reviews, meta-analyses, meta-syntheses, or other structured forms of evidence synthesis.

A Review or Evidence Synthesis should normally include:

  • Title

  • Abstract

  • Keywords

  • Introduction

  • Review aims and questions

  • Methods

  • Search strategy

  • Inclusion and exclusion criteria

  • Screening and selection procedures

  • Data extraction or appraisal approach

  • Results

  • Discussion

  • Limitations

  • Conclusion

  • References

  • Appendices, including search strategies, data extraction forms, or quality-appraisal instruments, where applicable

Authors should state clearly the type of review conducted, the rationale for the approach, and the procedures used to identify, select, appraise, and synthesise evidence.

Learning and Practice Articles

Learning and Practice Articles present reflective, practice-based, implementation-focused, or evaluative scholarship. They may include case studies, programme evaluations, implementation reports, participatory research, professional learning, or accounts of innovation in practice.

A Learning and Practice Article should normally include:

  • Title

  • Abstract

  • Keywords

  • Introduction

  • Context and rationale

  • Aims or objectives

  • Approach, intervention, or programme description

  • Methods of data collection or evaluation

  • Findings, outcomes, or learning

  • Reflection and critical analysis

  • Implications for practice, policy, or further research

  • Limitations

  • Conclusion

  • References

  • Appendices or supplementary materials, where applicable

Authors should be explicit about the evidence base for claims, the boundaries of the work, and the extent to which findings may be transferable to other contexts.

Editorials and Commentaries

Editorials and Commentaries present informed, analytical perspectives on issues relevant to the Journal’s community. They are normally invited or discussed with the editorial team before submission.

These contributions should be concise, clearly argued, and supported by appropriate evidence or scholarly context. They should not present unpublished empirical findings unless this has been agreed with the Editor.

Manuscript Preparation

Manuscripts should be prepared in clear, formal academic English. Authors should use consistent terminology, spelling, punctuation, capitalization, headings, and referencing throughout.

Manuscripts should include:

  • A concise and informative title.

  • An abstract of no more than 250 words.

  • Up to six keywords.

  • Continuous line numbering, where possible.

  • Clearly numbered sections and subsections.

  • Complete and accurate references.

  • Clearly labelled figures and tables.

  • Captions that allow figures and tables to be understood independently.

  • A data availability statement, where applicable.

  • A funding statement.

  • A conflict-of-interest statement.

  • Acknowledgements, where appropriate.

Authors should ensure that the title, abstract, keywords, and body text accurately reflect the content of the manuscript. Abstracts should identify the purpose, approach, principal findings or argument, and implications of the work.

Referencing

Authors should use a consistent referencing style appropriate to their field and article type. All in-text citations must correspond to entries in the reference list, and all reference-list entries must be cited in the text.

References should provide sufficient information for readers to locate the cited source. Authors are responsible for the accuracy of bibliographic details, including author names, titles, publication dates, page numbers, DOIs, and URLs.

Where available, DOIs should be included in the reference list.

Figures and Tables

Figures and tables should be used only where they add substantive value to the manuscript. They should be clearly labelled, numbered consecutively, and referred to in the text.

Authors must ensure that:

  • Figures and tables are legible and accessible.

  • Axes, units, scales, abbreviations, and symbols are clearly explained.

  • Sources are acknowledged where material is reproduced or adapted from another work.

  • Permissions have been obtained where required.

  • Captions provide sufficient context for interpretation.

Tables should not duplicate information that is fully presented in the text or figures.

Double-Anonymous Peer Review

The Journal uses double-anonymous peer review. Authors must remove identifying information from the manuscript file submitted for review.

The anonymized manuscript should not include:

  • Author names, initials, or signatures

  • Institutional affiliations

  • Acknowledgements

  • Identifying funding details

  • Self-citations that reveal authorship

  • File metadata that reveals author identity

  • References to the authors’ own prior work phrased in a self-identifying manner

  • Any other information that could reveal author identity

Author and contributor details must be entered only in the submission system. Authors are also asked to ensure that document properties and file metadata do not reveal their identity.

Authorship and Contributor-ship

Authorship should reflect substantial intellectual contribution and accountability for the published work. Each individual listed as an author should meet all of the following criteria:

  1. Substantial contributions to the conception or design of the work, or to the acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data for the work.

  2. Drafting the work or revising it critically for important intellectual content.

  3. Final approval of the version to be published.

  4. Agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work in ensuring that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work are appropriately investigated and resolved.

Individuals who contributed to the work but do not meet all authorship criteria should be acknowledged with their permission. Examples may include provision of technical assistance, writing assistance, general supervision, administrative support, or access to resources.

Honorary, gift, ghost, or unapproved authorship is not acceptable.

Conflicts of Interest

All authors must disclose financial, personal, professional, institutional, or other relationships that could be perceived to influence the work, its interpretation, or its publication.

Disclosures may include, but are not limited to:

  • Employment or consultancies.

  • Honoraria or speaking fees.

  • Ownership, equity, or financial interests.

  • Patents or intellectual-property interests.

  • Advisory-board or board membership.

  • Funding from commercial, governmental, or non-governmental organizations.

  • Personal or professional relationships.

  • Academic competition or prior disputes.

Authors should disclose the source of support, the role of the funder in the research, and any restrictions on publication or data access.

If there are no conflicts of interest, authors should include:

The authors declare no competing interests.

Funding

Authors must disclose all financial support for the work, including grants, fellowships, sponsorships, in-kind support, and institutional funding.

The funding statement should identify:

  • The funder or funders.

  • Grant or award numbers, where applicable.

  • The role of the funder, if any, in study design; data collection, analysis, or interpretation; manuscript preparation; or the decision to submit for publication.

  • Any restrictions imposed by the funder.

If the work received no specific funding, authors should include:

This research received no specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.

Data Availability and Reproducibility

Authors are encouraged to make data, code, protocols, instruments, and other research materials available where appropriate and lawful. The Journal supports transparency and reproducibility and expects authors to state clearly the availability of materials underlying their work.

A data availability statement should specify whether data or materials are:

  • Publicly available in a recognized repository.

  • Available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.

  • Available subject to ethical, legal, contractual, or privacy restrictions.

  • Contained within the article or its supplementary materials.

  • Not applicable to the submission.

Where data cannot be shared, authors should explain the restriction and describe the basis on which access may be requested, if applicable.

The Journal encourages the use of recognized reporting guidelines and study registration where these are standard practice in the relevant field.

Ethics Approval, Consent, Privacy, and Safeguarding

Where research involves human participants, communities, organizations, personal data, sensitive material, or vulnerable populations, authors must ensure that appropriate ethical review, consent, privacy protections, and safeguarding arrangements are in place.

Manuscripts should state, where applicable:

  • The ethics committee or institutional review board that approved the research, or the basis for an exemption.

  • Approval or exemption reference numbers, where appropriate.

  • The nature of consent obtained from participants.

  • How participant privacy, confidentiality, and anonymity were protected.

  • How data were collected, stored, anonymized, and accessed.

  • Any compensation provided to participants.

  • Safeguarding considerations and procedures.

  • Permissions for the use of third-party material.

The Journal does not accept manuscripts containing unprotected personal data, confidential information, or safeguarding-sensitive material. Authors should provide de-identified versions or a secure access statement where such material is necessary.

Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence

Authors must not present generative artificial-intelligence output as their own original intellectual contribution. Generative AI tools may not be listed as authors because they cannot take responsibility for the accuracy, integrity, and accountability of the work.

Where generative AI has been used in the preparation of a manuscript, authors must disclose its use transparently, including the tool, purpose, and extent of use. Authors remain fully responsible for verifying the accuracy, originality, and integrity of all submitted content.

Use of AI in ways that could compromise confidentiality, data protection, consent, research integrity, or authorship accountability is not permitted.

Licensing and Copyright

Authors retain copyright in their work where the Journal’s applicable license provides for this. Published articles are made available under the license stated on the article page.

Authors are responsible for ensuring that:

  • They hold or have obtained the rights necessary to submit and publish the work.

  • Third-party material has been cleared for reuse or is used under an applicable exception.

  • Permissions are documented and available to the editorial team on request.

  • The license selected is consistent with the rights of all contributors and rights holders.

Submission Procedure

To submit a manuscript, authors should:

  1. Register or log in to the Journal’s submission system.

  2. Select the appropriate section or article type.

  3. Read the submission instructions and confirm the submission checklist.

  4. Upload the anonymized manuscript file.

  5. Upload supplementary materials, where applicable.

  6. Enter contributor details, metadata, funding information, and conflict-of-interest disclosures.

  7. Provide any confidential comments for the Editor, where necessary.

  8. Review the submission carefully.

  9. Submit the manuscript.

Authors will receive an acknowledgement once the submission has been received.

Editorial Process

Submissions are initially screened by the editorial team for fit with the Journal’s scope, completeness, compliance with submission requirements, and adherence to ethical and publication standards.

Suitable submissions proceed to double-anonymous peer review. Authors may be asked to provide revisions in response to reviewer and editorial comments.

Possible editorial outcomes include:

  • Acceptance.

  • Minor revisions.

  • Major revisions.

  • Decline.

Authors will be notified of the editorial decision through the submission system.

Questions and Support

For questions about article types, manuscript preparation, anonymization, ethics, licensing, or the submission process, please contact:

Email: [Journal email address]