Peer Review
Peer review is a central component of the Hed‑Core Academic Commons Journal’s editorial process. It provides independent expert assessment of submitted work and helps the Editor determine whether a manuscript is suitable for publication, requires revision, requires further review, or is not ready for publication in the Journal.
The Journal uses double-anonymous peer review for Research Articles, Reviews and Evidence Syntheses, and Learning and Practice Articles. In double-anonymous peer review, reviewers do not know the identities of authors, and authors do not know the identities of reviewers.
Editorials and Commentaries may be invited or editorially considered and may not always undergo external peer review. Where an article has not undergone external peer review, this is stated clearly on publication.
This page explains how peer review operates in practice. The Peer Review Policy sets out the Journal’s formal requirements, standards, and procedures.
Peer review is advisory. Reviewers provide independent recommendations and constructive feedback, but final editorial decisions rest with the Editor.
Purpose of Peer Review
Peer review supports the quality, integrity, transparency, and usefulness of published scholarship.
It helps to:
-
Assess the relevance, originality, rigour, clarity, and contribution of submitted work.
-
Identify strengths, weaknesses, gaps, inconsistencies, and areas requiring clarification.
-
Support authors in improving the quality, accuracy, and communication of their work.
-
Provide editors with independent expert advice.
-
Protect the integrity of the scholarly record.
-
Ensure that editorial decisions are informed by relevant subject, methodological, or professional expertise.
-
Support fair, accountable, and transparent editorial decision-making.
Peer review is not a guarantee of publication, nor is it a substitute for the Editor’s responsibility to assess whether a submission meets the Journal’s aims, scope, ethical requirements, and publication standards.
What Is Peer Reviewed
The following article types normally undergo double-anonymous peer review:
-
Research Articles.
-
Reviews and Evidence Syntheses.
-
Learning and Practice Articles.
Editorials and Commentaries may be invited or editorially considered. They may not always undergo external peer review.
Supplementary materials may be considered as part of the review where they are necessary to assess the manuscript’s findings, methods, claims, analyses, or conclusions. Such materials may include datasets, code, protocols, instruments, multimedia, technical documentation, or other supporting files.
Peer Review Model
The Journal uses double-anonymous peer review.
Under this model:
-
Reviewers do not know the identities of authors.
-
Authors do not know the identities of reviewers.
-
Manuscripts and supporting files should be prepared in ways that protect author anonymity.
-
Reviewer identities are protected throughout the review process.
-
Reviewer reports are treated as confidential editorial materials.
The Journal normally seeks reports from at least two independent reviewers for each externally peer-reviewed manuscript. The Editor may make a justified alternative arrangement where appropriate expertise is unavailable or where the nature of the submission requires it.
Who Conducts Peer Review
Peer review is conducted by independent reviewers with relevant subject, methodological, professional, or practice-based expertise.
Reviewers may include:
-
Researchers and academics.
-
Practitioners with relevant professional expertise.
-
Methodologists, statisticians, and data scientists.
-
Policy specialists and analysts.
-
Clinicians, educators, or other professionals where relevant to the submission.
-
Community researchers or lived-experience experts where appropriate to the work.
Reviewers are selected on the basis of expertise, independence, availability, and freedom from conflicts of interest.
The Editor is responsible for selecting reviewers, managing the review process, considering reviewer reports, and making the final editorial decision. Where appropriate, the Editor may assign a Section Editor or Associate Editor to manage a submission.
The Peer Review Process
The standard peer-review process is:
-
Submission.
The author submits the manuscript, required declarations, and any supporting files through the Journal’s online submission system. -
Initial editorial assessment.
The Editor assesses whether the submission falls within the Journal’s aims and scope, meets submission requirements, and is suitable for peer review. -
Editorial decision to review.
The Editor may send the manuscript for review, request clarification or revision before review, decline the submission, or take another appropriate editorial action. -
Reviewer selection.
The Editor identifies reviewers with relevant expertise and no disqualifying conflicts of interest. -
Review invitation.
Reviewers receive an invitation setting out the review request, deadline, confidentiality expectations, and relevant Journal policies. -
Reviewer response.
Reviewers accept or decline the invitation. Reviewers who identify a conflict of interest or lack of expertise should decline or notify the Editor. -
Double-anonymous review.
Reviewers assess the anonymised manuscript and any approved supporting materials. -
Reviewer report.
Reviewers provide comments for the authors and, where appropriate, confidential comments for the Editor. -
Reviewer recommendation.
Reviewers provide a recommendation to assist the Editor’s assessment. -
Editorial assessment.
The Editor considers the manuscript, reviewer reports, recommendations, and relevant Journal policies. -
Editorial decision.
The Editor makes an initial decision, which may include acceptance, revision, further review, or rejection. -
Revision.
Where revisions are required, authors respond to reviewer comments and upload a revised manuscript. -
Further review.
Where necessary, revised manuscripts may be returned to the original reviewers or assessed by additional reviewers. -
Final editorial decision.
The Editor makes a final decision on whether the manuscript is accepted, rejected, or requires further action. -
Copyediting and production.
Accepted manuscripts proceed to copyediting, production, proof review, and publication.
OJS supports the editorial workflow through Submission, Review, Copyediting, and Production stages, with reviewer assignment, review rounds, revisions, and editorial decisions managed within the platform. 1256
Reviewer Recommendations
Reviewers may be asked to provide one of the following recommendations:
-
Accept Submission.
-
Revisions Required.
-
Resubmit for Review.
-
Decline Submission.
-
Resubmit Elsewhere.
-
See Comments.
A reviewer recommendation is advisory. It assists the Editor but does not determine the editorial decision.
The Editor may reach a different decision from that recommended by a reviewer where this is justified by the manuscript, the reviews, the Journal’s policies, or other relevant considerations.
Editorial Decisions
Editorial decisions may include:
-
Accept Submission.
The manuscript is accepted and proceeds to copyediting and production. -
Request Revisions.
The manuscript requires revisions before a final decision can be made. Revisions may be minor or major. -
Resubmit for Review.
The manuscript requires substantial revision and must be submitted for a new round of review. -
Decline Submission.
The manuscript is not suitable for publication in the Journal. -
Resubmit Elsewhere.
The manuscript is not suitable for the Journal in its current form but may be suitable for another publication after revision. -
See Comments.
The Editor requires further information, clarification, or assessment before making a decision.
Editorial decisions are based on the quality, relevance, originality, rigour, ethics, transparency, and contribution of the work. They are not based on the authors’ nationality, ethnicity, gender, religious belief, political belief, institutional prestige, or other irrelevant characteristics.
Revision and Further Review
Where revisions are required, authors should provide:
-
A revised manuscript.
-
A point-by-point response to reviewer comments.
-
A clear explanation of changes made.
-
An explanation where a reviewer comment has not been addressed.
-
Revised supplementary files, where applicable.
The Editor may assess the revision directly or send it for further review.
A new review round may be necessary where revisions are substantial, where reviewers’ concerns have not been adequately addressed, or where the Editor requires additional independent assessment.
Responsibilities in Peer Review
Authors
Authors are responsible for:
-
Submitting original work that has not been published elsewhere and is not under consideration by another journal.
-
Preparing manuscripts and supplementary files in ways that protect anonymity during double-anonymous review.
-
Removing identifying information from manuscripts, files, metadata, and document properties where necessary.
-
Disclosing relevant conflicts of interest.
-
Disclosing funding and other material support.
-
Disclosing material use of artificial-intelligence tools in accordance with the Journal’s Artificial Intelligence Policy.
-
Responding to reviewer comments clearly, respectfully, and comprehensively.
-
Completing revisions within the agreed timeframe.
-
Ensuring that all authors have approved the final version of the manuscript.
Reviewers
Reviewers are responsible for:
-
Responding promptly to review invitations.
-
Accepting reviews only where they have appropriate expertise and sufficient time.
-
Declining reviews where they cannot provide a fair, timely, or unbiased assessment.
-
Declaring relevant conflicts of interest before accepting a review.
-
Maintaining confidentiality throughout and after the review process.
-
Assessing manuscripts fairly, objectively, and constructively.
-
Providing specific, evidence-based, and respectful feedback.
-
Submitting reviews by the agreed deadline.
-
Reporting suspected research-integrity or publication-ethics concerns to the Editor.
-
Not using unpublished manuscripts, data, ideas, methods, or other materials for personal, professional, or commercial advantage.
Editors
Editors are responsible for:
-
Assessing whether submissions fall within the Journal’s aims and scope.
-
Ensuring that submissions meet basic editorial and ethical requirements.
-
Selecting appropriate, independent reviewers.
-
Managing review invitations, deadlines, and communications.
-
Protecting the confidentiality of submissions and reviewer identities.
-
Managing conflicts of interest.
-
Considering reviewer reports alongside the manuscript and relevant policies.
-
Making final editorial decisions.
-
Communicating decisions clearly to authors.
-
Ensuring that appropriate action is taken where research-integrity or publication-ethics concerns arise.
Confidentiality and Anonymity
Reviewers must keep manuscripts, supplementary files, data, reviewer reports, and other review materials confidential. They must not share them with colleagues, students, collaborators, or third parties without the Editor’s permission.
Reviewers must not use unpublished manuscripts, data, ideas, methods, or other information obtained through peer review for their own research, teaching, professional work, commercial purposes, or the advantage of another person or organisation.
Authors should prepare manuscripts and supplementary files in ways that protect their anonymity during double-anonymous review. This may include removing author names, affiliations, acknowledgements, identifying references, file metadata, and other identifying information.
Reviewers should not attempt to identify authors. Authors should not attempt to identify reviewers.
Conflicts of Interest
Reviewers must declare relevant conflicts of interest before accepting a review assignment.
Reviewers should decline or disclose a review where they have a personal, professional, financial, institutional, political, religious, or other interest that could reasonably affect their objectivity.
Examples may include:
-
Current or recent collaboration with an author.
-
Recent co-authorship.
-
Shared institutional affiliation.
-
Supervisory, doctoral, or mentoring relationships.
-
Close personal or family relationships.
-
Financial interests in the work, its subject matter, or a competing product.
-
Competitive research interests.
-
Strong ideological, political, or religious commitments relevant to the work.
-
Prior knowledge of the manuscript or its underlying work that could compromise impartiality.
If a reviewer is unsure whether an interest is relevant, they should contact the Editor before accepting or beginning the review.
Editors must also declare and manage conflicts of interest. Where an editor has a relevant interest in a submission, the manuscript should be handled by another qualified editor or through an alternative independent editorial process.
Read Conflict of Interest: /conflict-of-interest
Research Integrity Concerns
Reviewers should notify the Editor if they identify concerns that may affect the integrity, ethics, legality, or reliability of a submission.
Such concerns may include:
-
Suspected plagiarism.
-
Duplicate or redundant publication.
-
Fabrication or falsification of data.
-
Image manipulation.
-
Inadequate ethical approval.
-
Missing consent.
-
Confidentiality breaches.
-
Data availability concerns.
-
Undisclosed conflicts of interest.
-
Undisclosed AI use.
-
Concerns about authorship.
-
Concerns about the treatment of participants, communities, or animals.
-
Substantial similarity to another published or submitted work.
Reviewers should report concerns to the Editor rather than contacting authors directly or conducting their own investigation.
The Editor will assess concerns in accordance with the Journal’s Research Integrity, Publication Ethics, and Complaints and Appeals policies.
Read Research Integrity: /research-integrity
Read Publication Ethics: /publication-ethics
Read Complaints and Appeals: /complaints-and-appeals
Artificial Intelligence in Peer Review
Reviewers must not use generative artificial-intelligence tools to generate, analyze, evaluate, summarize, rewrite, or otherwise assist with peer-review reports unless the Journal has given prior written permission.
Reviewers must never upload unpublished manuscripts, supplementary files, data, images, reviewer reports, or other confidential materials to external AI tools.
Reviewers remain fully responsible for the accuracy, fairness, independence, and confidentiality of their reviews.
Authors must disclose material use of AI tools in accordance with the Journal’s Artificial Intelligence Policy.
Read the Artificial Intelligence Policy: /artificial-intelligence-policy
Become a Reviewer
The Journal welcomes expressions of interest from researchers, practitioners, methodologists, policy specialists, and other professionals with relevant expertise.
Reviewers should have:
-
Relevant subject, methodological, or professional expertise.
-
A commitment to fair, constructive, and timely review.
-
The ability to maintain confidentiality.
-
Freedom from disqualifying conflicts of interest.
-
Capacity to complete reviews within agreed deadlines.
-
A willingness to follow the Journal’s editorial and ethical policies.
To express interest in reviewing, please contact the Editorial Office.
Email: [Journal email address]
Appeals and Complaints
Authors may appeal an editorial decision where they believe that the decision was affected by a material error, a failure of process, an undisclosed conflict of interest, or another substantive concern.
Appeals should be submitted through the Journal’s Complaints and Appeals process and should identify the specific grounds for appeal.
Appeals are not opportunities to submit a new manuscript, repeat arguments already considered, or request a different editorial decision without new information or a clear procedural concern.
Read Complaints and Appeals: /complaints-and-appeals
Relationship to Other Policies
This page should be read alongside the Journal’s Peer Review Policy, Editorial Policies, Publication Ethics, Research Integrity, Authorship, Conflict of Interest, Artificial Intelligence Policy, Data Availability, and Complaints and Appeals policies.
Read Peer Review Policy: /peer-review-policy
Read Editorial Policies: /editorial-policies
Read Publication Ethics: /publication-ethics
Read Research Integrity: /research-integrity
Read Authorship: /authorship
Read Conflict of Interest: /conflict-of-interest
Read Artificial Intelligence Policy: /artificial-intelligence-policy
Read Data Availability: /data-availability
Read Complaints and Appeals: /complaints-and-appeals
Contact
For questions about peer review, reviewer invitations, review deadlines, confidentiality, conflicts of interest, review reports, editorial decisions, or becoming a reviewer, please contact:
Email: [Journal email address]
Related pages:
Peer Review Policy: /peer-review-policy
Peer Review Process: /peer-review-process
Reviewer Guidelines: /reviewer-guidelines
Become a Reviewer: /become-a-reviewer
Reviewer Recognition: /reviewer-recognition
For Authors: /for-authors
Editorial Policies: /editorial-policies
Publication Ethics: /publication-ethics
Research Integrity: /research-integrity
Authorship: /authorship
Conflict of Interest: /conflict-of-interest
Artificial Intelligence Policy: /artificial-intelligence-policy
Data Availability: /data-availability
Complaints and Appeals: /complaints-and-appeals
Contact: /contact