Peer Review Process
The Hed‑Core Academic Commons Journal uses double-anonymous peer review to provide independent, fair, and constructive assessment of suitable submissions.
This page explains the stages of the Journal’s peer-review process, the responsibilities of authors, reviewers, and editors, the types of editorial decisions, and what happens after a manuscript is accepted.
The process is designed to support quality, integrity, transparency, and useful feedback while protecting the confidentiality of authors and reviewers.
The Peer Review Policy sets out the Journal’s formal rules and standards. This page explains how the process operates in practice.
Overview
A manuscript submitted to the Journal normally passes through the following stages:
Submission
→ Initial editorial assessment
→ Decision to send for review
→ Reviewer selection
→ Review invitation
→ Reviewer response
→ Double-anonymous review
→ Reviewer reports and recommendations
→ Editorial assessment
→ Editorial decision
→ Revision, where required
→ Further review, where required
→ Final editorial decision
→ Copyediting
→ Production
→ Publication
The Journal normally seeks reports from at least two independent reviewers for each externally peer-reviewed manuscript. The Editor may make a justified alternative arrangement where appropriate expertise is unavailable or where the nature of the submission requires it.
Stage 1: Submission
Authors submit manuscripts through the Journal’s online submission system.
At submission, authors should provide:
The manuscript.
Title page or author information, where required by the submission system.
An anonymized manuscript file for double-anonymous review.
Abstract.
Keywords.
Declarations of funding, conflicts of interest, data availability, and AI use where applicable.
Supplementary files, where relevant.
Permissions for third-party material, where applicable.
Ethical approval information, where applicable.
Recommended reviewers, where permitted.
Opposed reviewers, where permitted and justified.
Authors must ensure that manuscripts and supporting files do not contain identifying information that would compromise double-anonymous review.
Read Author Guidelines: /author-guidelines
Read Submission Checklist: /submission-checklist
Stage 2: Initial Editorial Assessment
The Editor, or an authorized Associate Editor or Section Editor, assesses whether the submission is suitable for peer review.
The initial assessment considers whether the manuscript:
Falls within the Journal’s aims and scope.
Matches the requirements of the selected article type.
Is complete and readable.
Meets basic ethical and editorial requirements.
Includes required declarations and statements.
Protects author anonymity where double-anonymous review applies.
Demonstrates sufficient relevance, originality, rigour, and potential contribution.
Does not raise immediate research-integrity, legal, privacy, confidentiality, or safeguarding concerns.
At this stage, the Editor may:
Send the manuscript for peer review.
Return the manuscript to authors for clarification or revision before review.
Decline the submission without external review.
Take another appropriate editorial action.
A decision not to send a manuscript for external review does not necessarily reflect a negative judgement of the authors’ work. It may reflect limited fit with the Journal’s scope, insufficient originality or contribution, lack of readiness for review, or competing editorial priorities.
Stage 3: Reviewer Selection
Where a manuscript is sent for review, the Editor identifies potential reviewers with relevant expertise.
Reviewer selection considers:
Subject expertise.
Methodological expertise.
Professional or practice expertise.
Familiarity with the type of work submitted.
Independence from the authors.
Absence of disqualifying conflicts of interest.
Availability and ability to meet the review deadline.
Prior reviewing experience, where relevant.
Diversity of expertise and perspectives, where appropriate.
The Editor may consult reviewer records, author recommendations, editorial board members, and other appropriate sources when identifying reviewers.
Author-recommended reviewers are considered at the Editor’s discretion. The Editor is not obliged to invite recommended reviewers, particularly where independence, expertise, availability, or conflicts of interest are in question.
Read Conflict of Interest: /conflict-of-interest
Stage 4: Review Invitation
Selected reviewers receive an invitation through the Journal’s online system.
The invitation normally includes:
The manuscript title and abstract.
The review deadline.
The type of review requested.
Instructions for accessing the manuscript and supporting files.
The Journal’s reviewer guidance.
Confidentiality requirements.
Conflict-of-interest requirements.
Instructions for accepting or declining the invitation.
Contact information for questions.
Reviewers should respond promptly. Where a reviewer cannot complete the review, they should decline promptly so that the Editor can invite another reviewer.
Stage 5: Reviewer Response
Reviewers may accept or decline a review invitation.
A reviewer should accept only if they:
Have relevant expertise.
Have sufficient time to complete the review.
Can maintain confidentiality.
Have no disqualifying conflict of interest.
Can provide a fair and constructive assessment.
Are willing to follow the Journal’s editorial and ethical policies.
A reviewer should decline if they lack expertise, cannot meet the deadline, have a relevant conflict of interest, or cannot provide an impartial assessment.
Declining promptly is helpful to the Journal and to authors because it allows the Editor to invite another reviewer without unnecessary delay.
Stage 6: Double-Anonymous Review
Once a reviewer accepts the invitation, they gain access to the anonymized manuscript and any approved supporting files.
Reviewers assess the manuscript in relation to:
Relevance to the Journal’s aims and scope.
Originality and contribution.
Clarity of research question, aim, or purpose.
Appropriateness of the article type.
Soundness of the theoretical or conceptual framework, where applicable.
Appropriateness and transparency of methods.
Quality and integrity of data, analysis, evidence, or argument.
Accuracy of interpretation and conclusions.
Ethical conduct and compliance.
Appropriate use and citation of sources.
Quality of tables, figures, images, and supplementary materials.
Clarity, structure, and readability.
Completeness of reporting.
Limitations and implications.
Relevance to research, practice, policy, or public understanding.
Reviewers should assess the work in its own context. They should not reject a manuscript simply because it does not reflect their preferred theoretical approach, method, discipline, or professional perspective.
Stage 7: Reviewer Report
Reviewers provide a written report that should be:
Specific.
Constructive.
Evidence-based.
Respectful.
Clear.
Actionable.
Focused on the manuscript rather than the author.
A helpful reviewer report normally includes:
A brief summary of the manuscript.
An overall assessment of its contribution and suitability.
Major comments requiring attention.
Minor comments requiring attention.
Comments on methods, analysis, evidence, or interpretation.
Comments on clarity, structure, and presentation.
Comments on ethical or reporting issues, where relevant.
Comments on tables, figures, supplementary materials, or data availability, where relevant.
A recommendation to the Editor.
Reviewers should distinguish clearly between:
Essential issues that must be addressed
Important issues that should be addressed
Minor or optional suggestions
Reviewers should avoid vague comments, unsupported assertions, personal criticism, discriminatory language, or demands that authors adopt the reviewer’s own preferred approach without clear justification.
Stage 8: Confidential Comments to the Editor
Reviewers may provide confidential comments to the Editor.
These comments may include:
Concerns about research integrity.
Concerns about ethics, consent, privacy, or safeguarding.
Concerns about authorship.
Concerns about undisclosed conflicts of interest.
Concerns about undisclosed AI use.
Concerns about duplicate publication or plagiarism.
Concerns about the suitability of the manuscript for the Journal.
Concerns about the anonymity of the manuscript.
A private assessment that the reviewer does not wish to share directly with authors.
Confidential comments should be factual, specific, and professional. Reviewers should not use this section to introduce criticisms that should instead be shared transparently with authors.
Stage 9: Reviewer Recommendation
Reviewers provide a recommendation to assist the Editor’s assessment.
Possible recommendations include:
Accept Submission.
Revisions Required.
Resubmit for Review.
Decline Submission.
Resubmit Elsewhere.
See Comments.
A recommendation is advisory. It does not determine the editorial decision.
The Editor may reach a different decision from that recommended by a reviewer where this is justified by the manuscript, the reviews, the Journal’s policies, or other relevant considerations.
Stage 10: Editorial Assessment
The Editor considers:
The manuscript.
The Journal’s aims and scope.
The requirements of the relevant article type.
Reviewer reports and recommendations.
Confidential reviewer comments.
Ethical, legal, privacy, and safeguarding considerations.
Conflicts of interest.
Data and materials availability.
The quality of author responses, where the manuscript has been revised.
The Journal’s editorial priorities and capacity.
The Editor may consult another editor, seek additional advice, request further review, or contact the authors for clarification where necessary.
Stage 11: Editorial Decision
After the first review round, the Editor may make one of the following decisions:
Accept Submission
The manuscript is accepted and proceeds to copyediting and production.
This decision is normally made where the manuscript meets the Journal’s requirements and requires no further substantive revision.
Revisions Required
The manuscript requires revisions before a final decision can be made.
Revisions may be minor or major.
Minor revisions may involve clarification, presentation changes, referencing corrections, or limited additional information.
Major revisions may involve substantial changes to argument, methods, analysis, evidence, interpretation, structure, or reporting.
Resubmit for Review
The manuscript requires substantial revision and must be submitted for a new round of review.
This decision is normally used where the manuscript has potential but requires major changes that must be assessed through further peer review.
Decline Submission
The manuscript is not suitable for publication in the Journal.
This decision may be made because the work falls outside the Journal’s scope, lacks sufficient originality or contribution, has significant methodological or ethical concerns, or is not sufficiently developed for publication.
Resubmit Elsewhere
The manuscript is not suitable for the Journal in its current form but may be suitable for another publication after revision.
See Comments
The Editor requires further information, clarification, or assessment before making a decision.
Stage 12: Revision
Where revisions are requested, authors should submit:
A revised manuscript.
A point-by-point response to reviewer comments.
A clear explanation of changes made.
An explanation where a reviewer comment has not been addressed.
Revised supplementary files, where applicable.
Updated declarations, where necessary.
Authors should respond respectfully and specifically to reviewer comments. They should not simply state that they disagree with a comment without explaining why.
Where authors disagree with a reviewer, they may provide a reasoned response. The Editor will consider the response alongside the reviewer’s comments and the manuscript.
Stage 13: Further Review
The Editor may assess a revised manuscript directly or send it for further review.
Further review may involve:
The original reviewers.
One or more additional reviewers.
A reviewer with different expertise.
An editor or editorial board member with relevant expertise.
Further review is more likely where:
Revisions are substantial.
Reviewers’ concerns have not been adequately addressed.
New material or analyses have been added.
Ethical, integrity, or confidentiality concerns remain.
The Editor requires additional independent assessment.
Stage 14: Final Editorial Decision
After considering the manuscript, reviews, author responses, and any further review, the Editor makes a final decision.
The final decision may be:
Accept Submission.
Request further revisions.
Resubmit for Review.
Decline Submission.
Resubmit Elsewhere.
The Editor’s decision is final, subject to the Journal’s Complaints and Appeals process.
Read Complaints and Appeals: /complaints-and-appeals
Stage 15: Copyediting and Production
Accepted manuscripts proceed to copyediting and production.
This stage may include:
Copyediting for clarity, consistency, and style.
Checking references and citations.
Formatting tables, figures, and supplementary materials.
Preparing the article for online publication.
Proof review by authors.
Correction of approved proofs.
Assignment of publication metadata.
Assignment of a DOI, where applicable.
Publication in an issue or online-first collection.
Authors should respond promptly to copyediting and proofing queries. Substantial changes should not normally be introduced at proof stage unless they are necessary to correct an error or clarify meaning.
Stage 16: Publication
Once production is complete, the article is published.
Published articles are assigned to an issue or published online first, depending on the Journal’s publication arrangements.
The published article may include:
Title.
Authors and affiliations.
Abstract.
Keywords.
Main text.
References.
Tables and figures.
Supplementary materials.
Funding statement.
Conflict-of-interest statement.
Data Availability Statement.
AI-use disclosure, where applicable.
Licence and copyright information.
DOI or other persistent identifier, where applicable.
Publication date.
Article history, where displayed.
Timelines
Review timelines vary according to the availability of suitable reviewers, the complexity of the manuscript, the number of review rounds required, and the responsiveness of authors and reviewers.
The Journal seeks to manage peer review efficiently, but it cannot guarantee a fixed decision date.
Authors can help reduce delays by:
Submitting complete and anonymised manuscripts.
Providing accurate contact information.
Responding promptly to editorial queries.
Submitting revisions by the agreed deadline.
Providing clear responses to reviewer comments.
Avoiding unnecessary changes after acceptance.
Reviewers can help reduce delays by:
Responding promptly to invitations.
Accepting only reviews they can complete on time.
Meeting agreed deadlines.
Notifying the Editor promptly if circumstances change.
What Peer Review Does Not Guarantee
Peer review does not guarantee:
Acceptance.
Publication.
A particular decision.
A specific number of review rounds.
A fixed timeline.
Immunity from post-publication concerns.
Endorsement of the authors’ views, findings, or conclusions.
A published article has undergone editorial assessment and, where applicable, peer review. Publication does not mean that the Journal endorses every interpretation, claim, or recommendation made by authors.
Relationship to Other Pages
This page should be read alongside:
Peer Review: /peer-review
Peer Review Policy: /peer-review-policy
Reviewer Guidelines: /reviewer-guidelines
Become a Reviewer: /become-a-reviewer
Reviewer Recognition: /reviewer-recognition
For Authors: /for-authors
Author Guidelines: /author-guidelines
Submission Checklist: /submission-checklist
Editorial Policies: /editorial-policies
Publication Ethics: /publication-ethics
Research Integrity: /research-integrity
Conflict of Interest: /conflict-of-interest
Artificial Intelligence Policy: /artificial-intelligence-policy
Data Availability: /data-availability
Complaints and Appeals: /complaints-and-appeals
Contact: /contact
Contact
For questions about the peer-review process, review status, reviewer invitations, deadlines, revisions, or editorial decisions, please contact:
Email: [Journal email address]
Before publishing
Replace:
[Journal email address]
Then verify these links:
/peer-review
/peer-review-policy
/reviewer-guidelines
/become-a-reviewer
/reviewer-recognition
/for-authors
/author-guidelines
/submission-checklist
/editorial-policies
/publication-ethics
/research-integrity
/conflict-of-interest
/artificial-intelligence-policy
/data-availability
/complaints-and-appeals
/contact