Reviewer Guidelines

Peer reviewers make an essential contribution to the quality, integrity, fairness, and usefulness of the Hed‑Core Academic Commons Journal. Reviewers provide independent expert assessment of manuscripts and help authors improve their work while helping Editors reach informed editorial decisions.

Reviewing is a professional and scholarly responsibility. Reviewers are expected to assess manuscripts fairly, confidentially, independently, constructively, and within the agreed timeframe.

The Journal uses double-anonymous peer review for Research Articles, Reviews and Evidence Syntheses, and Learning and Practice Articles. Reviewers do not know the identities of authors, and authors do not know the identities of reviewers.

This page provides practical guidance for reviewers. It should be read alongside the Journal’s Peer Review, Peer Review Process, Peer Review Policy, Conflict of Interest, Research Integrity, Publication Ethics, and Artificial Intelligence Policy pages.

Role of the Reviewer

A reviewer is an independent subject, methodological, professional, or practice-based expert invited to assess a submitted manuscript.

Reviewers advise the Editor. They do not make the final decision to accept, revise, or decline a manuscript.

The Editor considers reviewer reports alongside the manuscript, the Journal’s aims and scope, the relevant article type, ethical requirements, editorial policies, author responses, and other relevant factors before reaching an editorial decision.

A reviewer’s role is to:

  • Assess the scholarly, methodological, professional, and practical quality of the work.

  • Identify strengths and weaknesses.

  • Assess whether methods, evidence, analysis, and conclusions are appropriate and sufficiently clear.

  • Help authors improve the accuracy, clarity, rigour, and usefulness of their work.

  • Identify ethical, integrity, confidentiality, privacy, or safeguarding concerns.

  • Provide the Editor with an informed recommendation.

  • Maintain the confidentiality and integrity of the peer-review process.

Peer review is not an opportunity to impose a preferred theoretical position, methodological approach, professional perspective, citation practice, or personal viewpoint on authors.

Before Accepting a Review

Reviewers should read the manuscript title and abstract carefully before accepting an invitation.

Accept an invitation only if you:

  • Have relevant subject, methodological, professional, or practice-based expertise.

  • Can assess the manuscript fairly and independently.

  • Have sufficient time to complete the review by the requested deadline.

  • Can maintain confidentiality.

  • Have no disqualifying conflict of interest.

  • Are willing to follow the Journal’s editorial, ethical, and AI-use requirements.

Decline the invitation promptly if you:

  • Lack sufficient expertise.

  • Cannot complete the review on time.

  • Have a personal, professional, financial, institutional, political, religious, or other relevant conflict of interest.

  • Have prior knowledge of the manuscript or its underlying work that may compromise impartiality.

  • Cannot maintain confidentiality.

  • Are unsure whether you can provide a fair and constructive assessment.

Where appropriate, a reviewer who declines may suggest another qualified reviewer. Suggested reviewers must not be close collaborators, personal associates, or individuals with a known conflict of interest.

Conflicts of Interest

Reviewers must declare relevant conflicts of interest before accepting a review.

Potential conflicts may include:

  • Current or recent collaboration with an author.

  • Recent co-authorship with an author.

  • Shared institutional affiliation.

  • Supervisory, doctoral, mentoring, or employment relationships.

  • Close personal or family relationships.

  • Financial interests in the work, a related product, organisation, service, or intervention.

  • Professional rivalry or direct competition.

  • Membership of the same project, network, centre, or research group.

  • Strong political, ideological, religious, or advocacy interests relevant to the work.

  • Prior involvement with the manuscript, dataset, funding application, protocol, or related confidential assessment.

If you are uncertain whether an interest is relevant, contact the Editor before accepting the review.

Do not assume that double-anonymous review removes the need to disclose a conflict. In some fields or specialist areas, reviewers may infer author identity from the subject, methods, references, data, setting, or prior work.

Read Conflict of Interest: /conflict-of-interest

Confidentiality

Manuscripts and all associated materials are confidential.

Reviewers must not:

  • Share the manuscript, supplementary files, data, figures, tables, code, reviewer report, editorial correspondence, or decision information with anyone without written permission from the Editor.

  • Discuss the manuscript with colleagues, students, collaborators, employers, clients, or other third parties.

  • Use information obtained through review for personal, professional, research, financial, commercial, or competitive advantage.

  • Retain copies of unpublished manuscripts or related files after the review process has concluded, unless the Editor instructs otherwise.

  • Contact the authors directly.

  • Identify themselves to authors through review comments, uploaded files, file metadata, or other communications.

If you wish to involve a trainee, colleague, or co-reviewer, obtain written permission from the Editor before sharing any manuscript material. Any approved co-reviewer must be identified to the Editor and must comply with the same confidentiality, conflict-of-interest, and ethical requirements.

Reviewers are expected to respect the confidentiality of manuscripts and not use information from them for personal advantage. 1248

Double-Anonymous Review

The Journal uses double-anonymous peer review.

To protect anonymity:

  • Do not include your name, institutional affiliation, or identifying details in comments to authors.

  • Do not upload review files containing identifying metadata or tracked changes that disclose your identity.

  • Do not refer to your own work, projects, experience, or professional role in a way that reveals your identity.

  • Do not contact authors directly.

  • Do not attempt to identify authors through external searches, social-media activity, preprint records, or professional networks.

  • Notify the Editor if you believe that author anonymity has been compromised.

If you recognise authors or believe you have identified them, do not reveal this in comments to authors. Inform the Editor confidentially if this knowledge creates a conflict of interest or affects your ability to review impartially.

Using the OJS Review System

The Journal manages reviews through Open Journal Systems.

After receiving an invitation, reviewers should:

  1. Log in to the Journal’s review system.

  2. Read the manuscript title, abstract, review deadline, and review request.

  3. Declare any conflict of interest.

  4. Accept or decline the invitation promptly.

  5. Download the anonymised manuscript and any approved supporting files.

  6. Read the Reviewer Guidelines and relevant Journal policies.

  7. Complete the review form and written comments.

  8. Upload any permitted review attachment, ensuring it contains no identifying information.

  9. Enter confidential comments for the Editor, where necessary.

  10. Select a reviewer recommendation.

  11. Submit the review before the deadline.

If you experience a technical problem, cannot access a file, need a deadline extension, or need clarification about the review request, contact the Editorial Office promptly.

Assessing the Manuscript

Reviewers should assess the manuscript in relation to the Journal’s aims and scope, the requirements of the article type, and the standards appropriate to the relevant field.

The questions below are guides. Not every question applies to every manuscript type.

Relevance and contribution

Consider whether:

  • The manuscript fits the Journal’s aims and scope.

  • The topic is relevant to research, practice, policy, professional learning, or public understanding.

  • The manuscript makes a clear, original, or useful contribution.

  • The purpose, research question, argument, or central claim is clearly stated.

  • The manuscript explains why the work matters.

  • The manuscript is sufficiently situated within relevant scholarship, practice, policy, or community context.

Originality and scholarship

Consider whether:

  • The manuscript makes a contribution beyond existing work.

  • Relevant literature, evidence, theories, methods, or practice knowledge are considered appropriately.

  • Sources are accurately represented and cited.

  • Claims are properly supported.

  • The manuscript avoids plagiarism, redundant publication, unsupported assertion, or inappropriate reuse of earlier work.

  • The work demonstrates appropriate intellectual honesty and transparency.

Methods and evidence

Consider whether:

  • The study design, approach, or method is appropriate to the question or purpose.

  • Methods are described clearly enough for readers to understand how the work was conducted.

  • Data sources, materials, participants, settings, sampling, procedures, and analytical approaches are described sufficiently.

  • The analysis is appropriate, transparent, and proportionate to the data or evidence.

  • The manuscript distinguishes evidence, interpretation, opinion, and speculation.

  • Limitations, uncertainties, and possible sources of bias are acknowledged.

  • Data, code, protocols, instruments, or supplementary materials are available where appropriate or their restrictions are explained clearly.

Results, findings, and interpretation

Consider whether:

  • Findings or results are presented clearly and accurately.

  • Tables, figures, images, and supplementary materials are necessary, comprehensible, and consistent with the text.

  • Interpretation is supported by the evidence presented.

  • Conclusions do not overstate what the evidence can support.

  • Alternative explanations, limitations, and uncertainty are considered where relevant.

  • Practical, theoretical, policy, or professional implications are justified.

Ethics and integrity

Consider whether:

  • Ethical approval, consent, permissions, registrations, or exemptions are stated where relevant.

  • Privacy, confidentiality, consent, safeguarding, cultural rights, and community interests have been addressed appropriately.

  • Conflicts of interest and funding are disclosed.

  • Data availability is addressed appropriately.

  • Any use of artificial intelligence is disclosed in accordance with the Journal’s Artificial Intelligence Policy.

  • There are concerns about plagiarism, duplicate publication, fabricated or falsified data, image manipulation, inappropriate authorship, undisclosed conflicts, or other possible misconduct.

Clarity and presentation

Consider whether:

  • The title accurately represents the manuscript.

  • The abstract provides an accurate and useful summary.

  • The manuscript is logically structured.

  • Headings and subheadings are clear.

  • Language is precise, respectful, and appropriate to the intended audience.

  • Terminology is defined where necessary.

  • Tables and figures are clearly labelled.

  • References are relevant, accurate, and appropriately used.

  • The manuscript is sufficiently readable for fair scholarly assessment.

Article-Type Considerations

Research Articles

For Research Articles, consider whether:

  • The research question or objective is clear.

  • The study design is appropriate.

  • Methods and analysis are sufficiently detailed and rigorous.

  • Findings are presented accurately.

  • Conclusions follow from the evidence.

  • Ethical approval, consent, registration, and data availability are addressed where applicable.

  • The contribution to knowledge, practice, or policy is clear.

Reviews and Evidence Syntheses

For Reviews and Evidence Syntheses, consider whether:

  • The review question or purpose is clear.

  • The review method is appropriate and sufficiently transparent.

  • Search, selection, appraisal, and synthesis processes are described adequately.

  • Relevant evidence is represented fairly.

  • Limitations of the evidence base and review process are acknowledged.

  • Conclusions and recommendations are proportionate to the evidence.

Learning and Practice Articles

For Learning and Practice Articles, consider whether:

  • The article provides a clear description of the practice, initiative, programme, innovation, intervention, or learning process.

  • Context is described sufficiently.

  • Evidence, evaluation, reflection, or learning is presented clearly.

  • Claims are proportionate to the available evidence.

  • The article identifies limitations, transferability, and lessons for others.

  • Ethical, privacy, consent, and safeguarding considerations are addressed where relevant.

Editorials and Commentaries

Editorials and Commentaries may not always undergo external peer review. Where you are asked to review one, consider whether:

  • The argument is clear, fair, and relevant.

  • Claims are accurate and appropriately supported.

  • The commentary distinguishes evidence from opinion.

  • The language is responsible, respectful, and non-discriminatory.

  • Potential conflicts of interest are disclosed.

Writing a Helpful Review

A helpful review is clear, specific, constructive, and respectful.

Your comments should focus on the manuscript, not the authors.

A useful review normally includes:

  • A brief summary of the manuscript and your overall assessment.

  • Key strengths.

  • Major comments on issues that must be addressed.

  • Minor comments on smaller but relevant improvements.

  • Specific references to sections, pages, paragraphs, line numbers, tables, figures, or supplementary materials where possible.

  • A recommendation to the Editor.

Use numbered comments where possible. This helps authors respond point by point and assists the Editor in understanding the basis of your assessment.

Distinguish clearly between:

  • Essential issues that must be addressed before publication can be considered.

  • Important issues that should be addressed to improve the manuscript.

  • Minor or optional suggestions that may improve clarity or presentation.

Constructive and Respectful Tone

Reviewers should write reviews in a professional, courteous, and constructive tone.

Appropriate comments focus on the work:

  • “The manuscript would benefit from a clearer explanation of the sampling approach.”

  • “The interpretation of these findings appears broader than the data presented; please clarify the basis for this conclusion.”

  • “The literature review would be strengthened by engagement with recent work on this issue.”

  • “The authors should explain how consent was obtained and how participant confidentiality was protected.”

  • “The table would be easier to interpret if the column headings and units of analysis were clarified.”

Inappropriate comments focus on the person:

  • “The authors do not understand the topic.”

  • “This is a poor attempt at research.”

  • “The writing is terrible.”

  • “This work should never have been submitted.”

  • “The authors are clearly biased.”

Reviewers should not make personal, discriminatory, hostile, humiliating, insulting, or dismissive comments. Reviewers should not criticise authors on the basis of nationality, ethnicity, gender, language background, religion, disability, institutional affiliation, career stage, political views, or other personal characteristics.

Constructive review should identify strengths, explain concerns with sufficient detail, and offer practical guidance rather than personal criticism. 1260

Recommendations and Comments to the Editor

Reviewers may be asked to select a recommendation such as:

  • Accept Submission.

  • Revisions Required.

  • Resubmit for Review.

  • Decline Submission.

  • Resubmit Elsewhere.

  • See Comments.

Your recommendation is advisory. The Editor makes the final decision.

Comments to authors should explain the basis for your assessment and provide constructive guidance for revision.

Confidential comments to the Editor may be appropriate for:

  • Suspected research misconduct.

  • Concerns about ethics, consent, privacy, confidentiality, or safeguarding.

  • Concerns about undisclosed conflicts of interest.

  • Concerns about authorship.

  • Concerns about duplicate publication, plagiarism, data fabrication, falsification, or image manipulation.

  • Concerns that may compromise double-anonymous review.

  • Concerns that cannot appropriately be shared with authors at that stage.

Confidential comments must remain factual, professional, and consistent with the substance of comments shared with authors. They should not be used to make unsupported accusations or introduce hidden criticisms that authors have no opportunity to address.

Citation Practices

Reviewers may suggest additional references only where they are genuinely relevant to the manuscript’s evidence, methods, context, analysis, interpretation, or claims.

Reviewers must not:

  • Require authors to cite the reviewer’s own work without a clear scholarly reason.

  • Require citation of a colleague’s work, a Journal article, or another publication solely to increase citation counts.

  • Use citation requests to promote a personal, institutional, commercial, or ideological interest.

  • Recommend references that the reviewer has not checked or that are not relevant.

If you suggest a reference with which you have a connection, disclose this to the Editor in confidential comments.

Artificial Intelligence and Review

Reviewers must not use generative artificial-intelligence tools to generate, analyse, evaluate, summarise, rewrite, or otherwise assist with peer-review reports unless the Journal has given prior written permission.

Reviewers must never upload or enter unpublished manuscript content, supplementary files, data, images, tables, code, reviewer reports, or confidential editorial correspondence into external AI tools.

Reviewers remain fully responsible for the accuracy, fairness, independence, confidentiality, and integrity of their reports.

Read Artificial Intelligence Policy: /artificial-intelligence-policy

Identifying Ethical or Integrity Concerns

If you identify a possible concern, report it confidentially to the Editor. Do not contact the authors directly and do not conduct an independent investigation.

Concerns may include:

  • Plagiarism or unattributed reuse of text, data, images, methods, or ideas.

  • Redundant or duplicate publication.

  • Fabrication, falsification, or selective reporting of data.

  • Image, figure, or data manipulation.

  • Inadequate or missing ethical approval.

  • Missing or inadequate consent.

  • Privacy, confidentiality, or safeguarding concerns.

  • Inappropriate authorship or contributorship.

  • Undisclosed conflicts of interest.

  • Undisclosed or inappropriate AI use.

  • Citation manipulation.

  • Misrepresentation of sources.

  • Misconduct involving research participants, communities, animals, or the environment.

The Editor will assess concerns in accordance with the Journal’s Research Integrity, Publication Ethics, and Complaints and Appeals policies.

Read Research Integrity: /research-integrity
Read Publication Ethics: /publication-ethics
Read Complaints and Appeals: /complaints-and-appeals

Timeliness and Extensions

Reviewers should accept or decline invitations promptly.

If you accept a review, submit it by the agreed deadline. If you need more time, contact the Editor or Editorial Office as early as possible.

If circumstances change and you cannot complete a review, notify the Editorial Office promptly. Early communication helps the Journal avoid unnecessary delays for authors and allows another reviewer to be invited if necessary.

After Submitting Your Review

After submitting a review:

  • Continue to treat the manuscript and review materials as confidential.

  • Do not discuss the manuscript or review with others.

  • Do not use information obtained through review for personal or professional advantage.

  • Be available, where possible, to assess a revised manuscript if invited.

  • Notify the Editor if you later identify a material concern relating to the manuscript or your review.

The Journal may contact reviewers for clarification where a report is unclear, incomplete, inappropriate, or appears inconsistent with the reviewer’s recommendation.

Reviewer Support and Recognition

The Journal recognizes that peer review is a significant contribution to scholarly and professional practice.

Reviewers may receive:

  • Confirmation of completed reviews.

  • Reviewer certificates, where available.

  • Annual acknowledgement, where reviewers have agreed to be identified.

  • Opportunities to record reviewing activity through recognised reviewer-recognition services where available.

  • Guidance, feedback, and support from the Editorial Office where appropriate.

Peer Review Policy

Read Reviewer Recognition: /reviewer-recognition

Contact

For questions about a review invitation, reviewer eligibility, conflict-of-interest disclosure, deadlines, technical problems, confidentiality, ethical concerns, or reviewer support, please contact:

Email: [Journal email address]

Related pages:

Peer Review: /peer-review
Peer Review Process: /peer-review-process
Peer Review Policy: /peer-review-policy
Become a Reviewer: /become-a-reviewer
Reviewer Recognition: /reviewer-recognition
Conflict of Interest: /conflict-of-interest
Research Integrity: /research-integrity
Publication Ethics: /publication-ethics
Editorial Policies: /editorial-policies
Artificial Intelligence Policy: /artificial-intelligence-policy
Complaints and Appeals: /complaints-and-appeals
Contact: /contact