Peer Review Policy
The Hed‑Core Academic Commons Journal uses double-anonymous peer review. Author and reviewer identities are concealed from one another during the review process to reduce the influence of personal, institutional, or reputational characteristics on editorial assessment.
Purpose of Peer Review
Peer review supports fair, informed, and accountable editorial decision-making. Reviewers assess the quality, relevance, clarity, ethics, and contribution of a submission and provide constructive feedback to assist the Editor and, where appropriate, the authors.
Peer review does not guarantee publication. Editorial decisions are based on reviewer recommendations, editorial assessment, and the Journal’s publication policies.
Submissions Subject to Peer Review
Research Articles, Reviews and Evidence Syntheses, and Learning and Practice Articles are subject to double-anonymous peer review.
Editorials, Commentaries, and other clearly identified editorial material may be published without external peer review where they are invited, editorially commissioned, or assessed solely through editorial review. Any such exception is identified clearly on publication.
Reviewer Selection
Reviewers are selected based on relevant subject expertise, methodological competence, familiarity with the relevant field, and absence of conflicts of interest.
Where appropriate, reviewers with complementary expertise may be invited to assess different dimensions of a submission. The Journal seeks reviewers who can provide fair, rigorous, constructive, and timely assessment.
Special Issues and Thematic Collections
Where a special issue or thematic collection is published, its manuscripts are subject to the same editorial and peer-review standards as regular submissions. Any guest editors involved in the handling of a submission will be subject to the Journal’s conflict-of-interest and editorial-independence requirements.
Reviewer Responsibilities
Reviewers are expected to:
-
Assess manuscripts objectively and within their area of expertise.
-
Maintain the confidentiality of manuscripts, data, and review materials.
-
Declare conflicts of interest before accepting a review.
-
Provide specific, respectful, and constructive feedback.
-
Identify strengths as well as weaknesses.
-
Distinguish between essential concerns and matters of preference.
-
Avoid disparaging, discriminatory, or unsupported commentary.
-
Report concerns relating to research integrity, ethics, consent, privacy, confidentiality, safeguarding, or publication misconduct.
-
Complete reviews within the agreed timeframe or notify the Editor promptly if unable to do so.
-
Refrain from using manuscript content for personal, professional, or commercial advantage.
Reviewers should not upload manuscripts, supplementary files, images, or confidential review materials to generative artificial-intelligence tools, as this may compromise confidentiality and data protection.
Author Responsibilities
Authors are expected to:
-
Submit anonymised manuscripts where required.
-
Respond promptly and professionally to editorial and reviewer comments.
-
Provide clear responses to substantive concerns.
-
Maintain confidentiality throughout the review process.
-
Avoid attempts to identify reviewers.
-
Disclose any new conflicts of interest or changes in circumstances that arise during review.
Editorial Responsibilities
Editors are expected to:
-
Assess submissions for fit, quality, completeness, and ethical compliance.
-
Select appropriate reviewers.
-
Protect reviewer and author anonymity.
-
Consider reviewer recommendations alongside editorial judgement.
-
Handle conflicts of interest transparently.
-
Ensure that confidential reviewer comments are not disclosed to authors.
-
Communicate decisions clearly and respectfully.
-
Maintain accurate records of editorial decisions and communications.
Review Criteria
Reviewers are asked to consider whether the submission:
-
Falls within the Journal’s aims and scope.
-
Makes a meaningful contribution to knowledge, practice, policy, or public understanding.
-
Presents a clear research question, argument, aim, or purpose.
-
Uses appropriate methods, sources, data, or evidence.
-
Reports its approach clearly and transparently.
-
Acknowledges limitations and relevant prior work.
-
Meets ethical and publication-integrity standards.
-
Communicates its argument clearly and accessibly.
Editorial Decisions
Possible editorial decisions include:
-
Accept.
-
Minor revisions.
-
Major revisions.
-
Decline.
Editorial decisions are based on reviewer feedback, editorial assessment, and the Journal’s publication standards. Decision letters will provide a clear explanation of the decision and, where applicable, identify the revisions required.
Confidentiality
All materials submitted to the Journal are treated as confidential. Manuscripts, supplementary files, reviewer reports, and editorial communications must not be shared outside the editorial process.
Authors should not attempt to identify reviewers. Reviewers should not contact authors directly without the Editor’s permission.
Conflicts of Interest
Reviewers, editors, and authors must declare financial, personal, professional, institutional, or other interests that could be perceived to influence their judgement.
Where a conflict of interest is identified, the Editor will determine whether the individual may participate in the editorial process and what safeguards are necessary.
Appeals
Authors who wish to appeal an editorial decision should contact the editorial office. Appeals should identify the manuscript, explain the grounds for appeal, and provide any relevant supporting information.
Appeals will be considered fairly, confidentially, and promptly.
Related pages:
Editorial Policies: /editorial-policies
Publication Ethics: /publication-ethics
Complaints and Appeals: /complaints-and-appeals
For Authors: /for-authors
Contact: /contact