Become a Reviewer

The Hed‑Core Academic Commons Journal welcomes expressions of interest from researchers, practitioners, methodologists, policy specialists, educators, and other professionals who wish to contribute to the quality, integrity, and development of scholarly and professional knowledge.

Peer reviewers provide independent expert assessment of submitted manuscripts. Their work helps the Editor make informed decisions, supports authors in improving their work, and strengthens the credibility and usefulness of published research, evidence syntheses, learning and practice scholarship, and commentary.

Reviewing is a voluntary scholarly contribution. It requires relevant expertise, independence, confidentiality, fairness, constructive communication, and a commitment to timely and responsible assessment.

Why Review for the Journal

Reviewing offers an opportunity to contribute to the quality of published knowledge and to participate in the scholarly and professional life of the Hed‑Core Academic Commons.

Reviewers may benefit from:

  • Contributing to the quality and integrity of published scholarship.

  • Engaging with new research, evidence, methods, and practice developments.

  • Strengthening critical appraisal, academic writing, and scholarly communication skills.

  • Building professional and scholarly networks.

  • Gaining experience relevant to research, editorial, and professional-development roles.

  • Receiving recognition for reviewing activity where available.

  • Supporting authors, particularly early-career researchers and practitioners, through constructive feedback.

  • Contributing to a more rigorous, inclusive, and responsible knowledge environment.

Reviewing is also a service to the wider research, professional, policy, and public communities that rely on credible knowledge.

Who May Review

The Journal welcomes expressions of interest from individuals with relevant expertise in areas aligned with its aims and scope.

Reviewers may include:

  • Researchers and academics.

  • Postgraduate students and early-career researchers with appropriate expertise.

  • Practitioners and professionals with relevant experience.

  • Methodologists, statisticians, and data scientists.

  • Policy analysts and public-sector professionals.

  • Educators, trainers, and professional-development specialists.

  • Clinicians, allied professionals, and other practice-based experts where relevant.

  • Community researchers and lived-experience experts where appropriate to the work.

  • Editors, librarians, archivists, and knowledge-translation specialists where relevant.

Reviewing is not restricted to senior academics. The Journal considers expertise, independence, availability, and ability to provide a fair and constructive review, rather than seniority alone.

Areas of Expertise

The Journal seeks reviewers with expertise relevant to its aims and scope, including but not limited to:

  • Research methods and research design.

  • Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed-methods research.

  • Systematic reviews and evidence synthesis.

  • Evaluation and programme assessment.

  • Policy analysis and public policy.

  • Professional practice and practice-based inquiry.

  • Education, learning, and professional development.

  • Health, wellbeing, and public health.

  • Social sciences and interdisciplinary research.

  • Data science, digital methods, and computational research.

  • Research ethics, governance, and integrity.

  • Open science, research data, and scholarly communication.

  • Community-engaged research and participatory approaches.

  • Knowledge translation, implementation, and evidence use.

  • Institutional research, organisational learning, and public administration.

This list is indicative rather than exhaustive. The Journal welcomes reviewers whose expertise is relevant to the work it publishes.

What Reviewing Involves

A reviewer is normally asked to:

  • Read an anonymised manuscript and any approved supporting materials.

  • Assess the manuscript against the Journal’s aims, scope, and relevant quality standards.

  • Identify strengths, weaknesses, gaps, and areas requiring clarification.

  • Provide constructive comments for authors.

  • Provide confidential comments to the Editor where necessary.

  • Select a recommendation to assist the Editor’s assessment.

  • Submit the review by the agreed deadline.

A typical review may take several hours, depending on the length and complexity of the manuscript, the number of review rounds, the quality of the submission, and the reviewer’s familiarity with the topic.

Reviewers are not expected to rewrite manuscripts, correct every language issue, or provide detailed line-by-line editing unless they wish to do so and the Editor has requested it.

Reviewer Requirements

Before accepting a review, reviewers should be able to confirm that they:

  • Have relevant expertise in the subject, methods, practice area, or article type.

  • Can assess the manuscript fairly, independently, and constructively.

  • Can maintain confidentiality.

  • Have no disqualifying conflict of interest.

  • Can meet the agreed review deadline.

  • Can use the Journal’s online review system.

  • Are willing to follow the Journal’s editorial, ethical, and AI-use requirements.

  • Are willing to disclose relevant conflicts of interest.

  • Are willing to report material ethical or integrity concerns to the Editor.

Reviewers should decline an invitation promptly where they lack the expertise, time, independence, or capacity to provide a fair and timely review.

Eligibility and Independence

Reviewers must be independent of the manuscript they assess.

You should not review a manuscript where you have:

  • A current or recent collaboration with an author.

  • Recent co-authorship with an author.

  • A shared institutional affiliation.

  • A supervisory, doctoral, mentoring, or employment relationship with an author.

  • A close personal or family relationship with an author.

  • A financial interest in the work, its subject matter, a related product, organisation, or intervention.

  • A direct professional rivalry or competing interest.

  • Membership of the same project, research group, centre, or network.

  • Strong political, ideological, religious, or advocacy interests that could compromise objectivity.

  • Prior knowledge of the manuscript, data, protocol, funding application, or related confidential assessment.

If you are unsure whether an interest is relevant, contact the Editor before accepting the invitation.

Read Conflict of Interest: /conflict-of-interest

Confidentiality

Reviewers must treat manuscripts, supplementary files, data, reviewer reports, and editorial correspondence as confidential.

Reviewers must not:

  • Share manuscripts or review materials with colleagues, students, collaborators, employers, clients, or third parties.

  • Discuss the manuscript publicly or privately without the Editor’s permission.

  • Use unpublished material for their own research, teaching, professional work, commercial purposes, or the advantage of another person.

  • Retain copies of manuscripts or related files after the review is complete, unless the Editor instructs otherwise.

  • Contact authors directly.

  • Attempt to identify authors or disclose reviewer identity.

If you wish to involve a trainee, colleague, or co-reviewer, obtain written permission from the Editor first. Any approved co-reviewer must be identified to the Editor and must comply with the same confidentiality, conflict-of-interest, and ethical requirements.

Artificial Intelligence

Reviewers must not use generative artificial-intelligence tools to generate, analyse, evaluate, summarise, rewrite, or otherwise assist with peer-review reports unless the Journal has given prior written permission.

Reviewers must never upload or enter unpublished manuscript content, supplementary files, data, images, tables, code, reviewer reports, or confidential editorial correspondence into external AI tools.

Reviewers remain fully responsible for the accuracy, fairness, independence, confidentiality, and integrity of their reviews.

Read Artificial Intelligence Policy: /artificial-intelligence-policy

Time Commitment

The time required to complete a review varies according to the manuscript’s length, complexity, article type, and the number of review rounds.

As a general guide, reviewers should be prepared to allocate sufficient time to:

  • Read the manuscript carefully.

  • Review supporting materials where relevant.

  • Check claims, methods, evidence, and references where necessary.

  • Prepare constructive comments.

  • Complete the review form.

  • Submit the review by the deadline.

The Journal will indicate the review deadline in the invitation. If you need additional time, contact the Editorial Office as early as possible.

How to Express Interest

To express interest in becoming a reviewer, please send an email to the Editorial Office with the following information:

  • Full name.

  • Preferred name or title, where applicable.

  • Institutional or professional affiliation.

  • Current position or role.

  • Email address.

  • ORCID iD, where available.

  • Areas of expertise.

  • Key subject areas, methods, or practice areas you are able to review.

  • Relevant professional or scholarly experience.

  • Examples of relevant publications, reports, projects, or professional work, where available.

  • Any relevant reviewing experience.

  • Languages in which you are able to review.

  • Confirmation that you are able to maintain confidentiality.

  • Confirmation that you will disclose relevant conflicts of interest.

  • Any accessibility requirements or support needs.

Please use the subject line:

text
 
 
Expression of Interest: Peer Reviewer

Email: [Journal email address]

Registering in the Journal System

Where the Journal uses Open Journal Systems, prospective reviewers may be asked to register as a Reader or Reviewer through the Journal’s online system.

After registration, reviewers may be asked to complete or update:

  • Name and preferred name.

  • Email address.

  • Institutional or professional affiliation.

  • Country or region.

  • Areas of expertise.

  • Reviewing interests.

  • ORCID iD, where available.

  • Biography or professional profile.

  • Reviewing history, where relevant.

  • Reviewer interests and availability.

Reviewers should ensure that their profile information remains accurate and up to date.

Selection of Reviewers

The Editor selects reviewers based on:

  • Relevance of expertise to the manuscript.

  • Methodological or professional competence.

  • Independence from the authors.

  • Absence of disqualifying conflicts of interest.

  • Availability and ability to meet deadlines.

  • Prior reviewing experience, where relevant.

  • Diversity of expertise and perspectives, where appropriate.

  • The needs of the manuscript and the Journal.

Registration as a reviewer does not guarantee an invitation to review. Invitations depend on the fit between a reviewer’s expertise and the manuscripts received, as well as reviewer availability and conflicts of interest.

Reviewer Development

The Journal supports reviewers by providing:

  • Clear reviewer guidance.

  • Information about the peer-review process.

  • Review forms and assessment criteria.

  • Confidentiality and conflict-of-interest requirements.

  • Editorial support where reviewers have questions.

  • Feedback where appropriate.

  • Opportunities to develop reviewing experience over time.

New reviewers are encouraged to begin with manuscripts closely aligned to their expertise and to seek support from the Editorial Office where needed.

Read Reviewer Guidelines: /reviewer-guidelines
Read Peer Review Process: /peer-review-process

Reviewer Recognition

The Journal recognises that peer review is a significant contribution to scholarly and professional practice.

Where appropriate, reviewers may receive:

  • Confirmation of completed reviews.

  • Reviewer certificates.

  • Annual reviewer acknowledgement.

  • Public recognition where reviewers have agreed to be identified.

  • Inclusion in reviewer-recognition services where available.

  • Opportunities to record reviewing activity for professional or institutional purposes.

Reviewer Recognition

Contact

To express interest in becoming a reviewer, update your reviewer profile, ask about reviewer eligibility, or request support with the review process, please contact:

Email: [Journal email address]

Related pages:

Peer Review: /peer-review
Peer Review Process: /peer-review-process
Reviewer Guidelines: /reviewer-guidelines
Reviewer Recognition: /reviewer-recognition
Peer Review Policy: /peer-review-policy
For Authors: /for-authors
Conflict of Interest: /conflict-of-interest
Research Integrity: /research-integrity
Publication Ethics: /publication-ethics
Artificial Intelligence Policy: /artificial-intelligence-policy
Contact: /contact