Reviewer Recognition

The Hed‑Core Academic Commons Journal recognizes that peer review is an essential contribution to scholarly and professional communication. Reviewers give their time, expertise, judgement, and care to help improve submitted work, support fair editorial decision-making, and protect the integrity of the published record.

Peer review is ordinarily voluntary and confidential. The Journal therefore seeks to acknowledge reviewer contributions in ways that are meaningful, accurate, proportionate, and consistent with double-anonymous peer review.

Recognition does not compromise reviewer anonymity, reveal confidential manuscript information, disclose editorial decisions, or imply that a reviewer endorses a published article.

Purpose

Reviewer recognition exists to acknowledge the time, expertise, and professional service contributed by reviewers; support the visibility of peer review as a valuable scholarly and professional activity; enable reviewers to document completed reviewing activity for professional development, appraisal, promotion, tenure, funding, institutional reporting, and professional portfolios where appropriate; encourage high-quality, fair, timely, and constructive peer review; build a sustainable and diverse reviewer community; and support the integrity, quality, and continuity of the Journal’s peer-review process.

Principles

The Journal’s approach to reviewer recognition is guided by the following principles:

Recognition should be accurate and based on genuine completed review activity.

Recognition should respect reviewer confidentiality and the Journal’s double-anonymous peer-review model.

Recognition should not reveal manuscript titles, author identities, reviewer comments, editorial decisions, or other confidential information unless the Journal and reviewer have expressly agreed otherwise.

Recognition should be fair, inclusive, and proportionate.

Recognition should not influence editorial decisions, peer-review recommendations, or the treatment of manuscripts.

Recognition should not be used to reward reviewers for recommending acceptance, rejection, or any particular editorial outcome.

Recognition should not create a financial, professional, or personal incentive that compromises reviewer independence.

Recognition may be withheld, delayed, corrected, or withdrawn where a review was incomplete, inappropriate, compromised, confidentially mishandled, or affected by misconduct.

Eligibility

A reviewer may be eligible for recognition where they have:

Accepted a formal review invitation from the Journal.
Completed and submitted a substantive review through the Journal’s review system.
Met the expected requirements of confidentiality, independence, professionalism, and timeliness.
Disclosed and appropriately managed any relevant conflicts of interest.
Complied with the Journal’s Peer Review Policy, Reviewer Guidelines, Research Integrity policy, Conflict of Interest policy, and Artificial Intelligence Policy.
Provided a review that the Editor considers usable for editorial assessment.

Recognition is not automatic merely because a reviewer accepts an invitation or accesses a manuscript.

The Journal may decide not to issue recognition where:

A review is not completed.
A review is substantially late without communication or agreed extension.
A review is materially incomplete, unconstructive, inappropriate, or unusable.
A reviewer has a disqualifying conflict of interest.
A reviewer breaches confidentiality.
A reviewer uses prohibited artificial-intelligence tools or uploads confidential material to an external service.
A reviewer engages in discriminatory, hostile, misleading, or unethical conduct.
There is a credible concern about misconduct, impersonation, or compromised peer review.

Forms of Recognition

The Journal may recognize reviewers through one or more of the following approaches.

Confirmation of completed review

The Journal may provide a confirmation email after a completed review has been submitted and acknowledged.

A confirmation may state that the reviewer completed peer-review service for the Journal. It should not disclose confidential manuscript information, author identity, reviewer comments, editorial decisions, or the outcome of the submission.

Reviewer certificate

The Journal may issue a certificate of recognition to eligible reviewers.

A reviewer certificate may include:

The reviewer’s name.
The Journal’s name.
The date or year of recognition.
A statement recognizing peer-review service.
The name or signature of an authorized Journal representative.
A certificate number, verification code, or QR code where such a system is available.

To protect confidentiality, a certificate should not normally include:

The manuscript title.
Author names or affiliations.
Reviewer comments.
The editorial decision.
Details that could reveal the identity of authors or reviewers.
Confidential submission, review, or production information.

Annual acknowledgement

The Journal may publish an annual acknowledgement of reviewers who have contributed during a defined period.

Publication of a reviewer’s name in an annual acknowledgement will occur only with the reviewer’s consent.

An annual acknowledgement may list names only. It should not associate reviewers with particular manuscripts, authors, editorial decisions, review reports, or subject areas unless the Journal has adopted an explicitly open review model and obtained appropriate consent.

Reviewer-Recognition Services

Where technically available and appropriate, the Journal may enable reviewers to record verified reviewing activity through recognized reviewer-recognition services or systems.

Any participation in an external recognition service will be optional and subject to:

Reviewer consent.
The Journal’s peer-review model.
Confidentiality obligations.
Applicable privacy and data-protection requirements.
The technical capabilities of the Journal platform.
The policies of the relevant recognition service.

The Journal will not share reviewer information with an external service without an appropriate lawful basis and the reviewer’s consent where consent is required.

ORCID and Professional Records

Where the Journal or its recognized service providers support verified reviewer-record deposits, reviewers may be able to connect completed reviews to their ORCID record or another professional profile.

Such arrangements must preserve confidentiality. Reviewers should not self-report confidential reviewing activity as verified Journal activity unless the Journal or an authorised recognition service has enabled that process.

The Journal may provide a reviewer with a confirmation or certificate that can be used in a curriculum vitae, annual review, promotion dossier, professional portfolio, or other legitimate record of service.

Reviewer Development and Support

Recognition may also include access to reviewer guidance, mentoring, feedback, training opportunities, or developmental support.

The Journal recognizes that meaningful appreciation includes helping reviewers develop their skills, particularly early-career reviewers and practitioners who are new to scholarly review.

Read Reviewer Guidelines: /reviewer-guidelines

Read Become a Reviewer: /become-a-reviewer

Recognition Does Not Mean Endorsement

Recognition acknowledges the reviewer’s contribution to the peer-review process. It does not mean that the Journal endorses the reviewer’s views, affiliations, publications, professional activities, or public statements.

Recognition also does not mean that:

The reviewer recommended acceptance of a manuscript.
The reviewer approved a published article.
The reviewer agrees with an article’s findings, interpretations, or conclusions.
The reviewer influenced the final editorial decision.
The reviewer has any editorial authority within the Journal.
The Journal guarantees future review invitations, editorial roles, publication opportunities, or other benefits.

Confidentiality and Double-Anonymous Review

The Journal uses double-anonymous peer review for eligible article types.

Reviewer recognition must preserve the confidentiality of authors, reviewers, manuscripts, reports, and editorial decisions.

The Journal will not ordinarily disclose:

Which manuscript a reviewer assessed.
Which authors were involved.
The content of reviewer reports.
The reviewer’s recommendation.
The Editor’s decision.
The date of review in a manner that could identify the submission.
Any confidential editorial correspondence.

Reviewers should not disclose their own review activity in a way that reveals confidential manuscript or author information.

If a reviewer receives a certificate or confirmation, they may use it for legitimate professional purposes. They should not alter it, misrepresent its meaning, or disclose confidential information connected to the review.

Recognition and Quality

Recognition is intended to value genuine reviewing service, not to create pressure to accept invitations or to encourage rushed, superficial, or biased reviews.

Reviewers are encouraged to accept only invitations that they can complete fairly, confidentially, independently, and within the agreed timeframe.

The Journal values:

Fairness.
Independence.
Constructive feedback.
Methodological and subject expertise.
Respectful communication.
Ethical awareness.
Timeliness.
Transparency about conflicts of interest.
Respect for confidentiality.

The quality and usefulness of a review matter more than the number of review invitations accepted.

Certificates and Verification

Where the Journal provides reviewer certificates, certificates may be generated manually or through the Journal’s publishing system.

The Journal may use verification measures such as:

A unique certificate number.
A secure verification code.
A QR code linking to a certificate-verification page.
An authorized electronic signature.
A record maintained by the Editorial Office.

If used, a public verification service should display only the minimum information needed to verify that a certificate is genuine. It should not disclose confidential manuscript details, author identities, review reports, recommendations, or editorial decisions.

Annual Reviewer Acknowledgement

Where the Journal publishes an annual acknowledgement, it should:

Cover a clearly stated period.
Include only reviewers who have permitted to be named.
Use the reviewer’s preferred professional name.
Avoid associating reviewers with particular manuscripts or decisions.
Be checked for accuracy before publication.
Provide a route for reviewers to request correction or removal.
Be published in a format that is accessible and easy to locate.

A reviewer may decline public acknowledgement without affecting their eligibility for other forms of recognition or future review invitations.

Withdrawal or Correction of Recognition

The Journal may correct, withhold, suspend, or withdraw recognition where necessary to protect the integrity of the Journal or the peer-review process.

This may occur where:

Recognition was issued in error.
A review was not genuinely completed.
The reviewer’s identity was misrepresented.
The review process was compromised.
Confidentiality was breached.
A serious undisclosed conflict of interest is identified.
Misconduct or unethical conduct is established.
A certificate contains inaccurate information.
Continued recognition would create a legal, ethical, privacy, safeguarding, or reputational risk.

Before withdrawing recognition, the Journal will normally seek clarification from the reviewer unless immediate action is necessary to prevent harm, preserve confidentiality, or protect the integrity of the review process.

Recognition Is Not Payment

Peer review for the Journal is normally voluntary and unpaid.

Recognition may include acknowledgements, certificates, verified records, training, or other non-financial forms of appreciation. It does not constitute employment, consultancy, authorship, editorial appointment, ownership, or entitlement to payment.

Any future decision to offer honoraria, fee waivers, access benefits, awards, or other material benefits would be governed by a separate published policy and would require safeguards to protect reviewer independence and editorial integrity.

Requesting Recognition

Eligible reviewers may request a confirmation of completed review activity or a reviewer certificate by contacting the Editorial Office.

Requests should include:

Full name.
Email address used for the review.
Approximate date or year of the completed review.
Any preferred name or affiliation for the certificate.
Any relevant accessibility requirement.

The Journal may verify the reviewer’s identity and review record before issuing recognition.

Email: [Journal email address]

Relationship to Other Pages

This page should be read alongside:

Peer Review: /peer-review
Peer Review Process: /peer-review-process
Peer Review Policy: /peer-review-policy
Reviewer Guidelines: /reviewer-guidelines
Become a Reviewer: /become-a-reviewer
Conflict of Interest: /conflict-of-interest
Research Integrity: /research-integrity
Publication Ethics: /publication-ethics
Privacy and Data Protection: /privacy-and-data-protection
Artificial Intelligence Policy: /artificial-intelligence-policy
Contact: /contact

Contact

For questions about reviewer certificates, annual acknowledgement, verification, recognition records, correction of recognition information, or reviewer-support arrangements, please contact:

Email: [Journal email address]

Before publishing

Replace:

[Journal email address]

Then verify these links:

/peer-review
/peer-review-process
/peer-review-policy
/reviewer-guidelines
/become-a-reviewer
/conflict-of-interest
/research-integrity
/publication-ethics
/privacy-and-data-protection
/artificial-intelligence-policy
/contact