Editorial Policies

The Hed‑Core Academic Commons Journal is committed to publishing scholarship of demonstrable quality, integrity, transparency, and social value. These policies govern the conduct of authors, reviewers, editors, and other contributors to the Journal.

The Journal’s editorial practices are informed by recognised principles of publication ethics, including transparency in editorial decision-making, responsible peer review, clear authorship standards, protection of research participants, and accountability in the handling of concerns and complaints.

Editorial Independence

Editorial decisions are made independently of commercial, political, religious, institutional, or personal interests. The Editor considers submissions on the basis of their scholarly merit, relevance, ethical conduct, clarity, and contribution to knowledge or practice.

No external party may influence the editorial decision for an individual manuscript. Where an editor, reviewer, or author has a conflict of interest, appropriate steps will be taken to manage or remove that conflict from the editorial process.

Editorial Decision-Making

The Editor is responsible for deciding which submissions are published. Decisions are informed by:

  • Editorial screening for scope, quality, completeness, and ethical compliance.

  • Reports from peer reviewers.

  • The significance and originality of the contribution.

  • The soundness of the methods, sources, data, or argument.

  • The clarity and accuracy of the presentation.

  • Compliance with the Journal’s ethical and publication policies.

  • The availability of appropriate expertise among reviewers.

Editorial decisions may include acceptance, minor revision, major revision, or decline. Decision letters will provide a clear explanation of the decision and, where applicable, identify the revisions required.

Peer Review

The Journal uses a double-anonymous peer-review model. Author and reviewer identities are concealed from one another during the review process.

Reviewer Selection

Reviewers are selected based on relevant subject expertise, methodological competence, familiarity with the relevant field, and absence of conflicts of interest.

The Journal seeks reviewers who can provide fair, rigorous, constructive, and timely assessment. Where appropriate, reviewers with complementary expertise may be invited to assess different dimensions of a submission.

Reviewer Responsibilities

Reviewers are expected to:

  • Assess manuscripts objectively and within their area of expertise.

  • Maintain the confidentiality of manuscripts, data, and review materials.

  • Declare conflicts of interest before accepting a review.

  • Provide specific, respectful, and constructive feedback.

  • Identify strengths as well as weaknesses.

  • Distinguish between essential concerns and matters of preference.

  • Avoid disparaging, discriminatory, or unsupported commentary.

  • Report concerns relating to research integrity, ethics, consent, privacy, confidentiality, safeguarding, or publication misconduct.

  • Complete reviews within the agreed timeframe or notify the Editor promptly if unable to do so.

  • Refrain from using manuscript content for personal, professional, or commercial advantage.

Reviewers should not upload manuscripts, supplementary files, images, or confidential review materials to generative artificial-intelligence tools, as this may compromise confidentiality and data protection.

Author Responsibilities During Review

Authors are expected to:

  • Submit anonymised manuscripts where required.

  • Respond promptly and professionally to editorial and reviewer comments.

  • Provide clear responses to substantive concerns.

  • Maintain confidentiality throughout the review process.

  • Avoid attempts to identify reviewers.

  • Disclose any new conflicts of interest or changes in circumstances that arise during review.

Authorship

Authorship should reflect substantial intellectual contribution and accountability for the published work. Each author should meet all of the following conditions:

  1. Substantial contributions to the conception or design of the work, or to the acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data for the work.

  2. Drafting the work or revising it critically for important intellectual content.

  3. Final approval of the version to be published.

  4. Agreement to be accountable for all aspects of the work in ensuring that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work are appropriately investigated and resolved.

Individuals who do not meet all authorship criteria may be acknowledged, with their consent, for specific contributions such as technical assistance, administrative support, provision of materials, general supervision, language editing, or access to resources.

The Journal does not permit honorary, gift, ghost, or unapproved authorship.

Changes to authorship

Requests to add, remove, or reorder authors after submission must be accompanied by:

  • A written explanation of the reason for the change.

  • Written approval from all previously listed authors.

  • Written approval from any newly added author.

  • Confirmation that the change complies with the Journal’s authorship criteria.

The Editor will consider such requests in light of the stage of publication, the reason for the change, and the availability of supporting documentation.

Originality, Plagiarism, and Duplicate Publication

Authors must submit original work. Text, data, figures, tables, images, code, ideas, or other material derived from other sources must be properly attributed.

The Journal does not accept:

  • Plagiarism.

  • Self-plagiarism without appropriate disclosure and permission.

  • Duplicate publication.

  • Redundant publication.

  • Salami slicing.

  • Unattributed reuse of previously published material.

  • Misrepresentation of publication status.

Where material has been published previously, authors must disclose this at submission and provide an explanation of how the present submission differs from, extends, or builds upon the earlier work.

Research Integrity

The Journal expects honesty, accuracy, and transparency in the conduct and reporting of research. The following constitute serious breaches of research and publication integrity:

  • Fabrication of data, results, sources, or findings.

  • Falsification or manipulation of data, images, results, or citations.

  • Inappropriate image manipulation.

  • Selective reporting or suppression of inconvenient findings.

  • Misrepresentation of authorship, affiliations, ethics approval, consent, or conflicts of interest.

  • Undisclosed use of material or data obtained without permission.

  • Breaches of participant confidentiality or privacy.

  • Improper use of generative artificial intelligence.

Concerns will be assessed fairly, confidentially, and in accordance with applicable institutional, legal, and editorial procedures.

Ethics, Consent, Privacy, and Safeguarding

Where research involves human participants, communities, organisations, personal data, sensitive material, or vulnerable populations, authors must ensure that appropriate ethical review, consent, privacy protections, and safeguarding arrangements are in place.

Authors must provide accurate information about:

  • Ethical approval or exemption.

  • The approving body and reference number, where appropriate.

  • Informed consent procedures.

  • Participant recruitment and compensation.

  • Privacy and confidentiality protections.

  • Data anonymisation, storage, access, and retention.

  • Safeguarding measures.

  • Permissions for the use of third-party material.

The Journal will not publish unprotected personal data, confidential information, or safeguarding-sensitive material.

Conflicts of Interest

Authors, reviewers, and editors must disclose relationships, activities, affiliations, funding sources, or other interests that could be perceived to influence their work or judgement.

Disclosures may include financial interests, employment, consultancies, honoraria, expert testimony, patents, equity holdings, advisory roles, personal relationships, academic competition, or institutional affiliations.

Where a conflict of interest is identified, the Editor will determine whether the individual may participate in the editorial process and what safeguards are necessary.

Funding Transparency

Authors must disclose all sources of financial support for the work. This includes grants, fellowships, sponsorships, institutional support, and in-kind contributions.

The funding statement should identify the funder, award number where applicable, and the role of the funder in the research and publication process. Authors should also disclose any restrictions imposed by funders on data access, publication, or reuse.

Data, Materials, and Reproducibility

The Journal supports transparency and reproducibility in research. Authors are encouraged to deposit data, code, protocols, instruments, and other research materials in appropriate repositories and to provide persistent identifiers where available.

A data availability statement must be included where applicable. It should state whether data, code, or materials are publicly available, available on request, restricted, or not applicable.

Where data cannot be shared because of privacy, ethical, legal, contractual, or confidentiality restrictions, authors must explain the restriction and describe any process for requesting access.

The Journal encourages the use of discipline-appropriate reporting guidelines and study registration where these are standard practice.

Generative Artificial Intelligence

Generative artificial-intelligence tools may not be listed as authors because they cannot accept responsibility for the accuracy, integrity, and accountability of scholarly work.

Where generative AI has been used in manuscript preparation, authors must disclose the tool, purpose, and extent of use. Authors remain fully responsible for verifying all content, ensuring originality, protecting confidential information, and complying with ethical and licensing requirements.

Reviewers and editors must not upload manuscripts, supplementary files, images, or confidential review materials to AI tools.

Open Access and Licensing

The Journal is committed to open access. Published articles are made freely available online under the licence stated on the article page.

Authors retain copyright where the Journal’s applicable licence provides for this. Authors are responsible for ensuring that third-party material is properly licensed, credited, or used within an applicable exception.

Corrections, Retractions, and Expressions of Concern

Where significant errors, ethical concerns, or integrity issues are identified after publication, the Journal may issue a correction, expression of concern, retraction, or other appropriate editorial notice.

The reason for the notice will be stated clearly and linked to the affected article where possible. The Journal will act in accordance with applicable editorial, legal, and institutional requirements.

Complaints, Concerns, and Appeals

Concerns about publication ethics, editorial conduct, reviewer conduct, author conduct, or editorial decisions should be directed to:

Email: [Journal email address]

Complaints should identify the relevant submission or article, explain the concern clearly, and provide supporting evidence where available.

Concerns will be handled fairly, confidentially, and promptly. Appeals against editorial decisions should explain why the author believes the decision should be reconsidered and should identify any material facts or procedural concerns not previously considered.